The proposal didn't get funded. The presentation fell flat. You didn't get the role. You tell yourself to learn from it, but mostly you just want to stop thinking about it. A week later, the lesson you meant to take away is still unclear.
That's very human. Research suggests failure can actually make learning harder.
What the research found
In 2019, Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Ayelet Fishbach published research in Psychological Science across five studies with 1,674 participants. People answered questions, received feedback that they had succeeded or failed, and were then tested on what they had learned.
People learned less from their own failures than from their own successes. But when they looked at someone else's failures, they learned about as much as from someone else's successes. The authors' explanation is that failure feels threatening to how we see ourselves, so we tune out the information it contains. In one study, how threatened people felt helped explain why they learned less from failing.
The findings have been debated. A 2025 commentary in the same journal argued that the way one of the main tasks was scored could make it look like people failed to learn when they hadn't, and the original authors replied that this doesn't explain all of their results. So treat this as an interesting idea rather than a settled fact. Still, the authors' practical point fits many people's experience: it's easier to learn from a setback when it doesn't feel like a verdict on you.
A setback is information about what happened, not a judgment of who you are.
Ways to learn without the sting
- Wait a day. Give the disappointment some room before you analyze it.
- Look at it like someone else's case. Ask, "If a colleague told me this happened, what would I notice?"
- Separate the event from yourself. Write "The pitch didn't land because..." rather than "I failed because..."
- Name one lesson, not ten. One clear takeaway is easier to use.
- Learn from others' setbacks too. Ask a trusted colleague what they learned from a time things didn't go their way. Their story can make yours feel less personal, and more useful.
Where an accountability partner helps
Setbacks are easier to face with someone in your corner. An accountability partner can listen without judging, help you look at what happened with some distance, and work out the one lesson worth keeping. They care that you reach your goals, which includes getting back up after a stumble.
This week
Think of one recent setback at work. Write about it in the third person, as if it happened to a colleague, and name one specific lesson. Notice how much lighter it feels to carry a lesson instead of a disappointment.
