The season of gatherings is starting: work parties, dinners with friends, holiday get-togethers. You know how the conversations will go. How's work? Any travel plans? Crazy weather. Pleasant, and forgettable. You'd love to talk about something real, but asking a deeper question feels risky. What if it's awkward?
It may be less awkward than you think.
What the research found
Michael Kardas, Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley published a series of experiments in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology on why people stick to small talk. According to the American Psychological Association, the research included 12 experiments with more than 1,800 participants. Many involved pairs of strangers discussing either shallow questions or deeper, more personal ones.
Across the experiments, people expected their conversations to be more awkward and less enjoyable than they turned out to be. That gap was larger for deep conversations. Participants also expected their partners to be less interested in going deep than the partners actually were. In one experiment, people who had both a shallow and a deep conversation expected to prefer the shallow one, but afterward preferred the deep one.
The authors suggest these mistaken expectations can keep people more shallow in conversation than would be good for them.
Most people are waiting for someone else to ask a better question.
Questions that open things up
You don't need to dive into anything painful. Try questions that invite a real answer:
- "What's something you're looking forward to next year?"
- "What's been the best part of your year so far?"
- "What are you working on that you're excited about?"
- "Who's someone who made a big difference in your life?"
- "What's something you've changed your mind about recently?"
Then listen, and share something real yourself. Depth usually goes both ways. A follow-up like "What made that so meaningful?" shows you're really interested and often opens the best part of the conversation.
Read the room
Not every moment is right for a deep conversation, and some people prefer to keep things light. Offer the question, and let the other person decide how far to go. If they keep it brief, that's fine. You've still signaled that you're interested in more than the surface.
Where an accountability partner helps
An accountability partner is someone in your corner who values the real conversations in your life. They can help you think about which relationships you'd like to deepen, and listen afterward when you want to share how a conversation went.
This week
At your next gathering, or over coffee with a friend or colleague, ask one question from the list above and really listen to the answer. Notice how much closer you feel when the conversation goes somewhere real.
- American Psychological Association: Getting beyond small talk: Study finds people enjoy deep conversations with strangers
- Kardas, Kumar and Epley, Overly Shallow?: Miscalibrated Expectations Create a Barrier to Deeper Conversation (APA)
- Chicago Booth Review: Deep conversations with strangers are more fulfilling than small talk
